Skip to main content

Installing Kubernetes on your Windows with Minikube

Personally I think if you are looking for a container management solution in today’s world, you have to invest your time in Kubernetes (k8s). There is no doubt about that because of multiple factors. To the best of my undestanding, these points include:




  • Kubernetes is Open Source

  • Great momentum in terms of activities & contribution at its Open Source Project

  • Decades of experience running its predecessor at Google

  • Support of multiple OS and infrastructure software vendors

  • Rate at which features are being released

  • Production readiness (Damn it, Pokemon Go met its scale due to Kubernetes)

  • Number of features available. Check out the list of features at the home page.


The general perception about a management solution like Kubernetes is that it would require quite a bit of setup for you to try it out locally. What this means is that it would take some time to set it up but more than setting it up, you might probably get access to it only during staging phase or something like that. Ideally you want a similar environment in your development too, so that you are as close to what it takes to run your application. The implications of this is that you want it running on your laptop/desktop, where you are likely to do your development.


This was the goal behind the minikube project and the team has put in fantastic effort to help us setup and run Kubernetes on our development machines. This is as simple and portable as it can get. The tagline of minikube project says it all: “Run Kubernetes locally”.









Side Note: The design of the minikube logo makes for interesting reading.

This post is going to take you through setting up Minikube on your Windows development machine and then taking it for a Hello World spin to see a local Kubernetes cluster in action. Along the way, I will highlight my environment and what I had to do to get the experimental build of minikube working on my Windows machine. Yes, it is experimental software, but it works!


If you are not on Windows, the instructions to setup minikube on either your Linux machine or Mac machine are also available here. Check it out. You can then safely skip over the setup and go to the section where we do a quick Hello World to test drive Kubernetes locally.


Keep in mind that Minikube gives you a single node cluster that is running in a VM on your development machine.



Of course, once you are done with what you see in this blog, I strongly recommend that you also look at Managed Container Orchestration solutions like Google Container Engine.

Let’s get started now with installation of minikube. But first, we must make sure that our development machine has some of the pre-requisites required to run it. Do not ignore that!



Using VirtualBox and not Hyper-V


VirtualBox and Hyperv (which is available on Windows 10) do not make a happy pair and you are bound to run into situations where the tools get confused. I preferred to use VirtualBox and avoid all esoteric command-line switches that we need to provide to enable creation of the underlying Docker hosts, etc.


To disable Hyper-V, go to Turn Windows features on or off and you will see a dialog with list of Windows features as shown below. Navigate to the Hyper-V section and disable it completely.



This will require a restart to the machine to take effect and on my machine, it even ended up doing a Windows Update, configuring it and a good 10 minutes later, it was back up.







Great! We have everything now to get going.



Development Machine Environment


I am assuming that you have a setup that is similar to this. I believe, you should be fine on Windows 7 too and it would not have the HyperV stuff, instructions of which I will give in a while.




  • Windows 10 Laptop. VT-x/AMD-v virtualization must be enabled in BIOS.

  • Docker Toolbox v1.12.0. The toolbox sets up VirtualBox and I have gone with that.

  • kubectl command line utility. This is the CLI utility for the Kubernetes cluster and you need to install it and have it available in your PATH. To install the latest 1.4 release, do the following: Go to the browser and give the following URL : http://storage.googleapis.com/kubernetes-release/release/v1.8.1/bin/windows/amd64/kubectl.exe. This will download the kubectl CLI executable. Please make it available in the environment PATH variable.


Note: kubectl versions are available at a generic location as per the following format: https://storage.googleapis.com/kubernetes-release/release/${K8S_VERSION}/bin/${GOOS}/${GOARCH}/${K8S_BINARY}

To find the latest kubectl version goto this link:  https://storage.googleapis.com/kubernetes-release/release/stable.txt

Minikube installation


The first step is to take the kubectl.exe file that you downloaded in the previous step and place that in the C:\ folder.


The next step is to download the minikube binary from the following location: https://github.com/kubernetes/minikube/releases


Go to the Windows download link as shown below:









This will start downloading the v0.22.3 release of the executable. The file name is minikube-windows-amd64.exe. Just rename this to minikube.exeand place it in C:\ drive, alongside the kubectl.exe file from the previous section.


You are all set now to launch a local Kubernetes one-node cluster!


All the steps moving forward are being done in Powershell. Launch Powershell in Administrative mode (Ctrl-Shift-Enter) and navigate to C:\ drive where the kubectl.exe and minikube.exe files are present.









A few things to note


Let’s do our standard testing to validate our utilities.









If you go to your %HOMEPATH%\.minikube folder now, you will notice that several folders got created. Take a look!


There are multiple commands that Minikube supports. You can use the standard ` — help` option to see the list of commands that it has:



PS C:\> .\minikube --help
Minikube is a CLI tool that provisions and manages single-node Kubernetes clusters optimized for development workflows

Usage:
minikube [command]

Available Commands:
dashboard Opens/displays the kubernetes dashboard URL for your local cluster
delete Deletes a local kubernetes cluster.
docker-env sets up docker env variables; similar to '$(docker-machine env)'
get-k8s-versions Gets the list of available kubernetes versions available for minikube.
ip Retrieve the IP address of the running cluster.
logs Gets the logs of the running localkube instance, used for debugging minikube, not user code.
config Modify minikube config
service Gets the kubernetes URL for the specified service in your local cluster
ssh Log into or run a command on a machine with SSH; similar to 'docker-machine ssh'
start Starts a local kubernetes cluster.
status Gets the status of a local kubernetes cluster.
stop Stops a running local kubernetes cluster.
version Print the version of minikube.

Flags:
--alsologtostderr[=false]: log to standard error as well as files
--log-flush-frequency=5s: Maximum number of seconds between log flushes
--log_backtrace_at=:0: when logging hits line file:N, emit a stack trace
--log_dir="": If non-empty, write log files in this directory
--logtostderr[=false]: log to standard error instead of files
--show-libmachine-logs[=false]: Whether or not to show logs from libmachine.
--stderrthreshold=2: logs at or above this threshold go to stderr
--v=0: log level for V logs
--vmodule=: comma-separated list of pattern=N settings for file-filtered logging

Use "minikube [command] --help" for more information about a command.


I have highlighted a couple of Global flags that you can use in all the commands for minikube. These flags are useful to see what is going on inside the hood at times and also for seeing the output on the standard output (console/command).


Minikube supports multiple versions of Kubernetes and the latest version is v1.7.5. To check out the different versions supported try out the following command:



PS C:\> .\minikube get-k8s-versions
The following Kubernetes versions are available:
- v1.7.5
- v1.7.4
- v1.7.3
- v1.7.2
- v1.7.0
- v1.7.0-rc.1
- v1.7.0-alpha.2
- v1.6.4
- v1.6.3
- v1.6.0
- v1.6.0-rc.1
- v1.6.0-beta.4
- v1.6.0-beta.3
- v1.6.0-beta.2
- v1.6.0-alpha.1
- v1.6.0-alpha.0
- v1.5.3
- v1.5.2
- v1.5.1
- v1.4.5
- v1.4.3
- v1.4.2
- v1.4.1
- v1.4.0
- v1.3.7
- v1.3.6
- v1.3.5
- v1.3.4
- v1.3.3
- v1.3.0

Starting our Cluster


We are now ready to launch our Kubernetes cluster locally. We will use the start command for it.



Note: You might run into multiple issues while starting a cluster the first time. I have several of them and have created a section at the end of this blog post on Troubleshooting. Take a look at it, in case you run into any issues.

You can check out the help and description of the command/flags/options via the help option as shown below:



PS C:\> .\minikube.exe start --help

You will notice several Flags that you can provide to the start command and while there are some useful defaults, we are going to be a bit specific, so that we can better understand things.


We want to use Kubernetes v1.7.5 and while the VirtualBox driver is default on windows, we are going to be explicit about it. At the same time, we are going to use a couple of the Global Flags that we highlighted earlier, so that we can see what is going on under the hood.


All we need to do is give the following command (I have separated the flags on separate line for better readability). The output is also attached.



PS C:\> .\minikube.exe start --kubernetes-version="v1.7.5" 
--vm-driver="virtualbox"
--alsologtostderr

W1004 13:01:30.429310    9296 root.go:127] Error reading config file at C:\Users\irani_r\.minikube\config\config.json: o
pen C:\Users\irani_r\.minikube\config\config.json: The system cannot find the file specified.
I1004 13:01:30.460582 9296 notify.go:103] Checking for updates...
Starting local Kubernetes cluster...
Creating CA: C:\Users\irani_r\.minikube\certs\ca.pem
Creating client certificate: C:\Users\irani_r\.minikube\certs\cert.pemRunning pre-create checks...
Creating machine...
(minikube) Downloading C:\Users\irani_r\.minikube\cache\boot2docker.iso from file://C:/Users/irani_r/.minikube/cache/iso
/minikube-0.7.iso...
(minikube) Creating VirtualBox VM...
(minikube) Creating SSH key...
(minikube) Starting the VM...
(minikube) Check network to re-create if needed...
(minikube) Waiting for an IP...
Waiting for machine to be running, this may take a few minutes...
Detecting operating system of created instance...
Waiting for SSH to be available...
Detecting the provisioner...
Provisioning with boot2docker...
Copying certs to the local machine directory...
Copying certs to the remote machine...
Setting Docker configuration on the remote daemon...
Checking connection to Docker...
Docker is up and running!
I1004 13:03:06.480550 9296 cluster.go:389] Setting up certificates for IP: %s 192.168.99.100
I1004 13:03:06.567686 9296 cluster.go:202] sudo killall localkube || true
I1004 13:03:06.611680 9296 cluster.go:204] killall: localkube: no process killed

I1004 13:03:06.611680    9296 cluster.go:202]
# Run with nohup so it stays up. Redirect logs to useful places.
sudo sh -c 'PATH=/usr/local/sbin:$PATH nohup /usr/local/bin/localkube --generate-certs=false --logtostderr=true --node
-ip=192.168.99.100 > /var/lib/localkube/localkube.err 2> /var/lib/localkube/localkube.out < /dev/null & echo $! > /var/r
un/localkube.pid &'

I1004 13:03:06.658605    9296 cluster.go:204]
Kubectl is now configured to use the cluster.
PS C:\>

Let us understand what it is doing behind the scenes in brief. I have also highlighted some of the key lines in the output above:




  1. It generates the certificates and then proceeds to provision a local Docker host. This will result in a VM created inside of VirtualBox.

  2. That host is provisioned with the boot2Docker ISO image.

  3. It does its magic of setting it up, assigning it an IP and all the works.

  4. Finally, it prints out a message that kubectl is configured to talk to your local Kubernetes cluster.


You can now check on the status of the local cluster via the status command:



PS C:\> .\minikube.exe status
minikubeVM: Running
localkube: Running

You can also use the kubectl CLI to get the cluster information:



PS C:\> .\kubectl.exe cluster-info
Kubernetes master is running at https://192.168.99.100:8443
kubernetes-dashboard is running at https://192.168.99.100:8443/api/v1/proxy/namespaces/kube-system/services/kubernetes-d
ashboard

To further debug and diagnose cluster problems, use 'kubectl cluster-info dump'.

Kubernetes Client and Server version


Let us do a quick check of the Kubernetes version at the client and server level. Execute the following command:



PS C:\> .\kubectl version
Client Version: version.Info{Major:"1", Minor:"4", GitVersion:"v1.7.5", GitCommit:"a16c0a7f71a6f93c7e0f222d961f4675cd97a
46b", GitTreeState:"clean", BuildDate:"2016-09-26T18:16:57Z", GoVersion:"go1.6.3", Compiler:"gc", Platform:"windows/amd6
4"}
Server Version: version.Info{Major:"1", Minor:"4", GitVersion:"v1.7.5", GitCommit:"a16c0a7f71a6f93c7e0f222d961f4675cd97a
46b", GitTreeState:"dirty", BuildDate:"1970-01-01T00:00:00Z", GoVersion:"go1.7.1", Compiler:"gc", Platform:"linux/amd64"
}

You will notice that both client and server are at version 1.4.



Cluster IP Address


You can get the IP address of the cluster via the ip command:



PS C:\> .\minikube.exe ip
192.168.99.100

Kubernetes Dashboard


You can launch the Kubernetes Dashboard at any point via the dashboardcommand as shown below:



PS C:\> .\minikube.exe dashboard

This will automatically launch the Dashboard in your local browser. However if you just want to nab the Dashboard URL, you can use the following flag:



PS C:\> .\minikube.exe dashboard --url=true
http://192.168.99.100:30000

There is a great post on how the Kubernetes Dashboard underwent a design change in version 1.4. It explains how the information is split up into respective sections i.e. Workloads , Services and Discovery, Storage and Configuration, which are present on the left-side menu and via which you can sequentially introspect more details of your cluster. All of this is provided by a nifty filter for the Namespace value above.


If you look at the Kubernetes dashboard right now, you will see that it indicates that nothing has been deployed. Let us step back and think what we have so far. We have launched a single-node cluster .. right? Click on the Node link and you will see that information:









The above node information can also be obtained by using the kubectl CLI to get the list of nodes.



PS C:\> .\kubectl.exe get nodes
NAME STATUS AGE
minikube Ready 51m

Hopefully, you are now able to relate how some of the CLI calls are reflected in the Dashboard too. Let’s move forward. But before that, one important tip!



Tip: use-context minikube


If you had noticed closely when we started the cluster, there is a statement in the output that says “Kubectl is now configured to use the cluster.” What this is supposed to do is to eventually set the current context for the kubectl utility so that it knows which cluster it is talking to. Behind the scenes in your %HOMEPATH%\.kube directory, there is a config file that contains information about your Kubernetes cluster and the details for connecting to your various clusters is present over there.


In short, we have to be sure that the kubectl is pointing to the right cluster. In our case, the cluster name is minikube.


In case you see an error like the one below (I got it a few times), then you need to probably set the context again.



PS C:\> kubectl get nodes
error: You must be logged in to the server (the server has asked for the client to provide credentials)

The command for that is:



PS C:\> kubectl config use-context minikube
switched to context "minikube".

Running a Workload


Let us proceed now to running a simple Nginx container to see the whole thing in action:


We are going to use the run command as shown below:



PS C:\> .\kubectl.exe run hello-nginx --image=nginx --port=80
deployment "hello-nginx" created

This creates a deployment and we can investigate into the Pod that gets created, which will run the container:



PS C:\> .\kubectl.exe get pods
NAME READY STATUS RESTARTS AGE
hello-nginx-24710... 0/1 ContainerCreating 0 2m

You can see that the STATUS column value is ContainerCreating.


Now, let us go back to the Dashboard (I am assuming that you either have it running or can launch it again via the minikube dashboard command):









You can notice that if we go to the Deployments option, the Deployment is listed and the status is still in progress. You can also notice that the Pods value is 0/1.


If we wait for a while, the Pod will eventually get created and it will ready as the command below shows:



PS C:\> .\kubectl.exe get pods
NAME READY STATUS RESTARTS AGE
hello-nginx-24710... 1/1 Running 0 3m

If we see the Dashboard again, the Deployment is ready now:









If we visit the Replica Sets now, we can see it:









Click on the Replica Set name and it will show the Pod details as given below:









Alternately, you can also get to the Pods via the Pods link in the Workloads as shown below:









Click on the Pod and you can get various details on it as given below:









You can see that it has been given some default labels. You can see its IP address. It is part of the node named minikube. And most importantly, there is a link for View Logs too.


The 1.4 dashboard greatly simplifies using Kubernetes and explaining it to everyone. It helps to see what is going on in the Dashboard and then the various commands in kubectl will start making sense more.


We could have got the Node and Pod details via a variety of kubectl describe node/pod commands and we can still do that. An example of that is shown below:



PS C:\> .\kubectl.exe describe pod hello-nginx-2471083592-4vfz8
Name: hello-nginx-2471083592-4vfz8
Namespace: default
Node: minikube/192.168.99.100
Start Time: Tue, 04 Oct 2016 14:05:15 +0530
Labels: pod-template-hash=2471083592
run=hello-nginx
Status: Running
IP: 172.17.0.3
Controllers: ReplicaSet/hello-nginx-2471083592
Containers:
hello-nginx:
Container ID: docker://98a9e303f0dbf21db80a20aea744725c9bd64f6b2ce2764379151e3ae422fc18
Image: nginx
Image ID: docker://sha256:ba6bed934df2e644fdd34e9d324c80f3c615544ee9a93e4ce3cfddfcf84bdbc2
Port: 80/TCP
State: Running
Started: Tue, 04 Oct 2016 14:06:02 +0530
Ready: True
Restart Count: 0
Volume Mounts:
/var/run/secrets/kubernetes.io/serviceaccount from default-token-rie7t (ro)
Environment Variables: <none>

..... /// REST OF THE OUTPUT ////

Expose a Service


It is time now to expose our basic Nginx deployment as a service. We can use the command shown below:



PS C:\> .\kubectl.exe expose deployment hello-nginx --type=NodePort
service "hello-nginx" exposed

If we visit the Dashboard at this point and go to the Services section, we can see out hello-nginx service entry.









Alternately, we can use kubectl too, to check it out:



PS C:\> .\kubectl.exe get services
NAME CLUSTER-IP EXTERNAL-IP PORT(S) AGE
hello-nginx 10.0.0.24 <nodes> 80/TCP 3m
kubernetes 10.0.0.1 <none> 443/TCP 1h

PS C:\> .\kubectl.exe describe service hello-nginx
Name: hello-nginx
Namespace: default
Labels: run=hello-nginx
Selector: run=hello-nginx
Type: NodePort
IP: 10.0.0.24
Port: <unset> 80/TCP
NodePort: <unset> 31155/TCP
Endpoints: 172.17.0.3:80
Session Affinity: None
No events.

We can now use the minikube service to understand the URL for the service as shown below:



PS C:\> .\minikube.exe service --url=true hello-nginx
http://192.168.99.100:31155

Alternately, if we do not use the url flag, then it can directly launch the browser and hit the service endpoint:



PS C:\> .\minikube.exe service hello-nginx
Opening kubernetes service default/hello-nginx in default browser...







View Logs


Assuming that you have accessed the service once in the browser as shown above, let us look at an interesting thing now. Go to the Service link in the Dashboard.









Click on the hello-nginx service. This will also show the list of Pods (single) as shown below. Click on the icon for Logs as highlighted below:









This will show the logs for that particular Pod and with HTTP Request calls that was just made.









You could do the same by using the logs <podname> command for the kubectl CLI:



PS C:\> .\kubectl logs hello-nginx-2471083592-4vfz8
172.17.0.1 - - [04/Oct/2016:09:00:33 +0000] "GET / HTTP/1.1" 200 612 "-" "Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) Appl
eWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/53.0.2785.143 Safari/537.36" "-"
2016/10/04 09:00:33 [error] 5#5: *1 open() "/usr/share/nginx/html/favicon.ico" failed (2: No such file or directory), cl
ient: 172.17.0.1, server: localhost, request: "GET /favicon.ico HTTP/1.1", host: "192.168.99.100:31155", referrer: "http
://192.168.99.100:31155/"
172.17.0.1 - - [04/Oct/2016:09:00:33 +0000] "GET /favicon.ico HTTP/1.1" 404 571 "http://192.168.99.100:31155/" "Mozilla/
5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/53.0.2785.143 Safari/537.36" "-"
PS C:\>

Scaling the Service


OK, I am not yet done!


When we created the deployment, we did not mention about the number of instances for our service. So we just had one Pod that was provisioned on the single node.


Let us go and see how we can scale this via the scale command. We want to scale it to 3 Pods.



PS C:\> .\kubectl scale --replicas=3 deployment/hello-nginx
deployment "hello-nginx" scaled

We can see the status of the deployment in a while:



PS C:\> .\kubectl.exe get deployment
NAME DESIRED CURRENT UP-TO-DATE AVAILABLE AGE
hello-nginx 3 3 3 3 1h

Now, if we visit the Dashboard for our Deployment:









We have the 3/3 Pods available. Similarly, we can see our Service or Pods.









or the Pod list:









Stopping and Deleting the Cluster


This is straightforward. You can use the stop and delete commands for minikube utility.



Limitations


Minikube is a work in progress at this moment and it does not support all the features of Kubernetes. Please refer to the minikube documentation, where it clearly states what is currently supported.



Troubleshooting Issues on Windows 10


My experience to get the experimental build of minikube working on Windows was not exactly a smooth one, but that is to be expected from anything that calls itself experimental.


I faced several issues and hope that it will save some time for you. I do not have the time to investigate deeper into why some of the stuff worked for me since my focus is to get it up and running on Windows. So if you have some specific comments around that, that will be great and I can add to this blog post.


In no order of preference, here you go:



Use Powershell


I used Powershell and not command line. Ensure that Powershell is launched in Administrative mode. This means Ctrl + Shift + Enter.



Put minikube.exe file in C:\ drive


I saw some issues that mentioned to do that. I did not experiment too much and went with C:\ drive.



Clear up .minikube directory


If there were some issues starting up minikube first time and then you try to start it again, you might see errors that say stuff like “Starting Machine” or “Machine exists” and then a bunch of errors before it gives up. I suggest that you clear up the .minikube directory that is present in %HOMEPATH%\.minikube directory. In my case, it is C:\Users\irani_r\.minikube. You will see a bunch of folders there. Just delete them all and start all over again.


To see detailed error logging, give the following flags while starting up the cluster:



--show-libmachine-logs --alsologtostderr

Example of the error trace for me was as follows:



PS C:\> .\minikube start --show-libmachine-logs --alsologtostderr
W1003 15:59:52.796394 12080 root.go:127] Error reading config file at C:\Users\irani_r\.minikube\config\config.json: o
pen C:\Users\irani_r\.minikube\config\config.json: The system cannot find the file specified.
I1003 15:59:52.800397 12080 notify.go:103] Checking for updates...
Starting local Kubernetes cluster...
I1003 15:59:53.164759 12080 cluster.go:75] Machine exists!
I1003 15:59:54.133728 12080 cluster.go:82] Machine state: Error
E1003 15:59:54.133728 12080 start.go:85] Error starting host: Error getting state for host: machine does not exist. Re
trying.
I1003 15:59:54.243132 12080 cluster.go:75] Machine exists!
I1003 15:59:54.555738 12080 cluster.go:82] Machine state: Error
E1003 15:59:54.555738 12080 start.go:85] Error starting host: Error getting state for host: machine does not exist. Re
trying.
I1003 15:59:54.555738 12080 cluster.go:75] Machine exists!
I1003 15:59:54.790128 12080 cluster.go:82] Machine state: Error
E1003 15:59:54.790128 12080 start.go:85] Error starting host: Error getting state for host: machine does not exist. Re
trying.
E1003 15:59:54.790128 12080 start.go:91] Error starting host: Error getting state for host: machine does not exist
Error getting state for host: machine does not exist
Error getting state for host: machine does not exist

Disable Hyper-V


As earlier mentioned, VirtualBox and Hyper-V are not the happiest of co-workers. Definitely disable one of them on your machine. As per the documentation of minikube, both virtualbox and hyperv drivers are supported on Windows. I will do a test of Hyper-V someday but I went with disabling Hyper-V and used VirtualBox only. The steps to disable Hyper-V correctly were shown earlier in this blog post.


 

Comments

  1. Your blog is in a convincing manner, thanks for sharing such an information with lots of your effort and time
    Kubernetes online training India
    Kubernetes online training Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice Blog!! Great Post !! Like your Blog and your ideas and i think its beneficial for us and i keep to visit your blog regularly because i got lot of information through you blog

    Digital Marketing Training in Chennai

    Digital Marketing Course in Chennai

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Terraform

Terraform is a tool for building, changing, and versioning infrastructure safely and efficiently. Terraform can manage existing and popular service providers as well as custom in-house solutions. Configuration files describe to Terraform the components needed to run a single application or your entire datacenter. Terraform generates an execution plan describing what it will do to reach the desired state, and then executes it to build the described infrastructure. As the configuration changes, Terraform is able to determine what changed and create incremental execution plans which can be applied. The infrastructure Terraform can manage includes low-level components such as compute instances, storage, and networking, as well as high-level components such as DNS entries, SaaS features, etc. The key features of Terraform are: Infrastructure as Code : Infrastructure is described using a high-level configuration syntax. This allows a blueprint of your datacenter to be versioned and

Java 8 coding challenge: Roy and Profile Picture

Problem:  Roy wants to change his profile picture on Facebook. Now Facebook has some restriction over the dimension of picture that we can upload. Minimum dimension of the picture can be  L x L , where  L  is the length of the side of square. Now Roy has  N  photos of various dimensions. Dimension of a photo is denoted as  W x H where  W  - width of the photo and  H  - Height of the photo When any photo is uploaded following events may occur: [1] If any of the width or height is less than L, user is prompted to upload another one. Print " UPLOAD ANOTHER " in this case. [2] If width and height, both are large enough and (a) if the photo is already square then it is accepted. Print " ACCEPTED " in this case. (b) else user is prompted to crop it. Print " CROP IT " in this case. (quotes are only for clarification) Given L, N, W and H as input, print appropriate text as output. Input: First line contains  L . Second line contains  N , number of

Salt stack issues

The function “state.apply” is running as PID Restart salt-minion with command:  service salt-minion restart No matching sls found for ‘init’ in env ‘base’ Add top.sls file in the directory where your main sls file is present. Create the file as follows: 1 2 3 base: 'web*' : - apache If the sls is present in a subdirectory elasticsearch/init.sls then write the top.sls as: 1 2 3 base: '*' : - elasticsearch.init How to execute saltstack-formulas create file  /srv/pillar/top.sls  with content: base : ' * ' : - salt create file  /srv/pillar/salt.sls  with content: salt : master : worker_threads : 2 fileserver_backend : - roots - git gitfs_remotes : - git://github.com/saltstack-formulas/epel-formula.git - git://github.com/saltstack-formulas/git-formula.git - git://github.com/saltstack-formulas/nano-formula.git - git://github.com/saltstack-f